All joking aside, polygamist marraiges often times come as a result of abuse to the women. Often women dont have a real choice in the matter.I am sure any civilized society would outlaw human/animal sacrifice. I am not sure where plural marriage would hurt anyone but the poor husband And I agree who would want more than one wife. I sure wouldn’t if I was a guy but if our constitution really does mean what it says then they should be able to follow their religion. But again I think it’s fair not to allow violent behavior even if it is part of a religion.
But based on the argument that you made before based on the first amendment, human sacrafice should be legal as long as it falls within the guidelines of a religion. Rastafariansim is a reasonable example. Where a part of a the religion is outlawed in America.
I would agree that government should play as small a role as possible in religion. Including taking into account a single sermon given by a certain candidates pastor, and blowing it out of proportion.When the Mormons split it was over the plural marriage. The union refused to let Utah in as a state unless they abandon the plural marriage. Their prophet had an instant prophecy that plural marriages were wrong, it broke up the group. The people who practice it today really believe its part of how they get to heaven.
The constitution says all men are created equal, yet they who wrote it had slaves and only some could vote. We have perfected (well made better) the constitution by insisting all men and women are equal. The founders were wrong when they said we had freedom of religion then insisted that the Mormons couldn’t practice theirs. As we changed the definition of all men are created equal we should also consider other religions who practice polygamy. Mormons are not the only ones. Islam practices it, Jewish people used to but put a 1000 year self ban on it.
But again I do not think the government as any rights or business in peoples relationships.
I will also certainly agree that the writers of the constitution wrote things they didnt practice, and probably had no intention of practicing.
The fact of the matter is that polygamy is illegal in every state in America. No matter if it is under the guise of a religion or a philandering spouse. There is not a single place in America where this is legally allowable. These people if the evidence shows they committed polygamy and probably child rape and sexual assault will be convicted and face whatever punishment that comes along with it.