Coyote
Well-Known Member
France didn't recognize a German threat until it came marching down down the Champs Elysee and the Nazi flag was flying from the Eiffel Tower.
We didn't either.
France didn't recognize a German threat until it came marching down down the Champs Elysee and the Nazi flag was flying from the Eiffel Tower.
Yep, WW I was the worst war in history to be a soldier in. WW II was worse if you were a civilian, but the trenches of WW I were five years of Hell like General Sherman never dreamed of. At the end of it a big chunk of northern France looked like the surface of the moon, only bloodier, nothing but craters and rats and entrails.
My point wasn't to single out just France in the coalition. My point was that the French certainly weren't cowards or "surrender monkeys". They suffered a 75% casualty rate, lost around 1.5 million men.
Umm..I already brought up the battle of Verdun and the fact that a good portion of French soldiers died charging German Machine Gun Nests.
I suppose I equate "glory" to efficiency and success. The French were certainly in it from beginning to end and it was their country that took the brunt of the fighting. I just don't see anything particularly glorious in a whole bunch of people dying for no gain.
Now Napoleon - that guy was glorious. And no where near as short as everyone seems to think he was.
Actually, now the French look as the Napoleon era as "the dark years." They see him as a tyrant and something to be ashamed of. But I guess for somebody like Armchair General that thinks Saddam was a hero, Napoleon could fit the bill.
Actually, now the French look as the Napoleon era as "the dark years." They see him as a tyrant and something to be ashamed of. But I guess for somebody like Armchair General that thinks Saddam was a hero, Napoleon could fit the bill.
Anyone who thinks Saddam is a hero should be given an 'educational video' of people being gassed, maimed, having their balls castrated etc. for a couple of hours. Preferably digitally edited so its their loved ones.
From a review and commentary on the French election, to an extended rehash of France's military history and prowess past? Goodness! Not to say that one is totally disconnected with the other, but are we to lose the significance of what is happening there today with a historical debate?
Right now France is standing at the edge of their future, determining how they want to shape it, and where they want it to fit with the rest of the world. I can only hope that this political shift will spawn a massive dose of reality that will inspire the world and spread throughout Europe like wildfire!
You don't pull any punches do you?
ArmChair General--THANK YOU for setting the facts straight about the French. You are absolutely right! I'm so sick of these "office smartasses" (to quote you) bashing the French. That "piss your dockers" comment is the best line I've probably ever heard pertaining to that subject! You really hit the nail on the head about the French. Doesn't it scare you that so many of us Americans are so poorly versed in history that such stupid, largely-inaccurate, inferences about our own allies can emerge into popular belief? Again, kudos on your comments!
Verdun. Just that name was enough to make Frenchmen and Germans, the few who survived it, wake up yelling for years afterward. The French lost 1.5 million men out of a total population of 40 million fighting the Germans from 1914-1918. A lot of those guys died charging German machine-gun nests with bayonets.
I'd really like to see one of you office smartasses joke about French being cowards with a French soldier, 1914 vintage. You'd piss your dockers.