Jarlaxle
Well-Known Member
Bay's numbers are good, but he doesn't strike fear in the opposition like Manny did.
No, but ask any pitcher who they'd rather face right now: Manny Ramirez, Kevin Youkilis, or Dustin Pedroia? My money is on most choosing Manny.
They HAVE good power...the only real holes are at shortstop (I see Lowrie filling that nicely in about a year) and at catcher. Varitek's hitting has nose-dived...he's wearing down badly (he's a very, very worn 36) at the plate. However, they NEED to re-sign him, I do not care if he hits .180 next year. First, there really isn't anyone else out there (except an aging, wearing-out Pudge Rodriguez, who isn't one-tenth the defensicve player 'Tek is), and second, they have lots of young pitchers who NEED his expertise. Case in point: Papelbon hasn't shaken him off since LAST SPRING. He trusts Variten that much. He should be platooned (reality check: Josh Beckett can call his own game), catching maybe three games in five (of course, Cash catches Wakefield).
Ramirez is the best pure hitter in baseball.
5 years ago, maybe. Not anymore...he HAS lost batspeed, and possibly some of his keen eyesight. (He's 37, IIRC.)
Remember Ortiz was just a journeyman player until he came to Boston and started hitting in front of Manny.
And having healthy knees due to not playing first base on the Metrodome's turf anymore.