and yes I recall what Bush did...the problem is...he did it...and where has that gotten us today?
It has gone a long way in restricting North Korea's freedom of action.. it has been much more successful that you are letting on.
Unless we can get China, who has shown its not willing I think most can see, to cut off its help of North Korea...the leadership will stand, it will still have a powerful military, it will still have nukes, and it will still be a aggressor looking to to make shows of force to get the worlds attention and force us to bargain....and those actions could grow in size if they don't get what they want...leading to actions we may not have control over.
We never had control of their actions to begin with... why would that change?
I agree the solution is going to be China, but do you think China is going to suddenly "get on board" when we start saber rattling?
Sanctions I think can work..in a place like Iran..where the people, while limited have a voice and do have a understanding of whats going on...I am not sure the people of North Korea are going to put the pressure on there leaders to make the changes we need to see happen.
Probably not, but they don't have to either persay.
Also just putting as much Econ pressure as we can on them...could force some powers within Korea to move and possibly see a coup...but as for if who took over would be better is hard to say...I don't have much knowledge, nor do I think many in our government...of who such people could be, or how they would react.
I can think of less desirable scenarios than a coup.
so far our "containing" of North Korea has ended up with them getting nukes, sinking Naval ships, Firing on towns with Artillery....Now from a overall standpoint, the ship and Island issue could be lived with ( given the worse options) but how Secure can we feel with North Korea , as a nuclear power, and its current leadership....under and sense of "contained"
Our current policy toward North Korea, from Clinton to Bush to Obama has hardly been one of containment.
Unless the US is willing to lean on China enough, I think our Efforts are going to fall short...and the US does not have the willpower to lean on China as hard as needed I think.
And do you think leaning on China militarily is going to get us anywhere?