Most everyone can identify with 50% or better of libertarian thought. But most hold tight to parts of anti libertarian thought that protects something they value.As a Christian, I agree that libertarianism feels right. It's all about free will, and I was taught that God is about free will as well. Of course, that's the simplistic version.
I think true conservatives and old school liberals would find a lot of common ground with each other and with libertarians. People are just too caught up in labels to see it, unfortunately.